Topics
Each topic gives you the dos and don’ts first, then the exact wording from the governing documents and the HOA, so you can check it yourself.
Holiday lighting & decorations
Temporary holiday lights and decorations are fine within the HOA’s date window. Permanent roofline lighting systems need Design Review Committee (DRC) approval first, and the HOA says it’s enforcing that this season.
Do
- Put decorations up no more than 30 days before a holiday and take them down within 20 days after.
- Use temporary lights that are shielded or aimed so the light stays on your own lot.
- Submit a DRC application before installing permanent lights (Govee-, Jellyfish-, or Trimlight-style systems), and get written approval. This season the review fee is $50 (usually $250), with no $500 deposit.
- Keep approved permanent lights off outside the holiday windows.
- Get any HOA approval or answer in writing.
Don’t
- Install permanent roofline lighting without DRC approval, even if the installer says it’s “just holiday lights.”
- Light the whole house in colored light so the entire property glows.
- Point lights at neighbors’ homes or the street, or use lights bright enough to disturb neighbors.
- Put decorations on Association property: common landscaping, slopes, walls, trails, or the Rec Center.
Key dates, 2026–27 season
Using the HOA’s 30-days-before and 20-days-after window. For permanent lighting, the HOA says “holidays” means federal legal holidays (when the post office and banks close).
| Holiday | Lights on from | Off by |
|---|---|---|
| Thanksgiving (Thu, Nov 26, 2026) | Oct 27, 2026 | Dec 16, 2026 |
| Christmas (Fri, Dec 25, 2026) | Nov 25, 2026 | Jan 14, 2027 |
| New Year’s Day (Fri, Jan 1, 2027) | Dec 2, 2026 | Jan 21, 2027 |
What the CC&Rs say
“Outdoor holiday decorations, or indoor holiday decorations that are visible from outside, shall be limited to a reasonable period of time prior to the date of the holiday, as determined by the Association in the Association Rules, and shall be removed as and when required by the Association Rules.”
“Any exterior electrical, gas or other artificial lighting installed on any Residence shall be positioned, screened, or otherwise directed or situated and of such controlled focus and intensity so as to fall on the same Residential Lot on which such lighting is located. Further rules regarding exterior lighting may be promulgated by the Board.”
Unless approved through Design Review (Article 8), “outside installations, including … wiring … and other Improvements” are prohibited. This is why the HOA treats permanent roofline lighting as an architectural improvement.
What the Rules (Handbook) say
“Holiday Decorations may be displayed 30 days prior and 20 days after the holiday. No decorations can be placed upon any Association Property.”
“Devices which may unreasonably disturb others are prohibited. These include, but are not limited to, (i) bright lights …”
What the HOA told homeowners
From Keystone Pacific, November 19, 2026: “We have an update too regarding the submittal to the architectural dept. for review of permanent lighting. The cost for the review will only be $50, not the usual $250. And no $500 deposit will be required. If approved, lighting can be on 30 days prior to the holiday and off by 20 days after the holiday. Holidays are legal holidays recognized by the federal government. (post office is closed, banks etc.)”
From the Board of Directors (resent the same day): “These permanent roofline lighting systems are architectural improvements, not temporary holiday decorations. They require an architectural application and written DRC approval, regardless of how the installer markets them. These MUST be preapproved.”
“Lighting the entire property in colored bulbs so the entire property glows in color is NOT permitted.”
“We are enforcing the violation policy for owners who have permanent lighting that have not been approved. Colored lighting that illuminates the entire property will also be part of the enforcement. Oceanside code enforcement has also been advised. A special hearing may be held to begin the fines for the unapproved lighting. We want everyone to enjoy the holidays so please use temporary light systems that are shielded so as to not illuminate the entire property.”
North River Farms Board of Directors, via Keystone Pacific
The Board’s email also cites Oceanside Municipal Code §39.5(d), which it says requires residential exterior lighting to be shielded or directed so direct light doesn’t extend beyond the property, and treats light trespass as a nuisance. We’re still confirming the exact wording of that section.
Where the HOA’s email goes beyond the documents
The November 19 notice says more than the CC&Rs and Rules do. These points come from the Board’s reading of the documents, not from their written text:
- The colored-lighting ban isn’t written in the CC&Rs. The email cites §6.13.4, but that section only says light has to stay on your own lot. Nothing in the CC&Rs or Rules mentions color. The ban on whole-house colored lighting is the Board’s reading of §6.13.4 and the “bright lights” rule.
- “Unreasonably disturbs neighbors” isn’t in §6.13.4 either. That wording is closer to the Rules’ Disruptive Devices section, which is the more direct basis for limiting bright displays.
- “Holidays” as federal holidays is new. The Rules just say “the holiday” and don’t define it. The federal-only definition appears for the first time in this email, and only for permanent lighting.
- The city code citation isn’t confirmed yet. The Board cites Oceanside Municipal Code §39.5(d). We’re checking the exact wording.
Known ambiguities
- Non-federal holidays. Under the federal-only definition, approved permanent lights have no on-window for Halloween, Hanukkah, Diwali, Lunar New Year, and other non-federal holidays. It’s unclear whether temporary decorations for those holidays fall under the same definition.
- Back-to-back holidays. The Thanksgiving, Christmas, and New Year’s windows overlap, running from Oct 27 to Jan 21. The HOA hasn’t said whether lights can stay on straight through.
- Between holidays. The emails don’t say whether approved permanent tracks can stay installed year-round. The natural reading is that they stay up and stay off.
- The $50 fee. It isn’t clear whether the reduced fee and waived deposit are for this season only or have a deadline.
- Lights already installed. The notice doesn’t say how much time owners with unapproved permanent lights have to apply before enforcement starts, or whether an application in progress pauses fines.
- White vs. colored. Plain white permanent lights still need DRC approval, since the requirement is about the installation, not the color. It isn’t clear whether approved lights may use color for part of the house, or only white.
We’re working on more answers. We’re asking HOA management for written answers to these questions and will update this page as they come in. Have an answer from the HOA, or a question to add? Send it to info@northriverfarmswatch.org.
Questions about your own lights? Ask HOA management (Keystone Pacific) in writing, and keep their written answer.
Fines & hearings
You get notice and a chance to be heard before the HOA can fine you, and you can fix the problem before the hearing.
- Notice of Hearing must arrive at least 10 days before the hearing. A courtesy notice is optional, so the hearing notice may be the first one you get.
- You can cure the violation before the hearing, and you can speak to the Board or respond in writing.
- Fine schedule: $100 to $5,000 for not complying with the CC&Rs or Rules. A continuing violation, like an unapproved architectural change, can count as a new violation every 30 days, but a hearing is required before new fines.
- Architectural violations (like unapproved permanent lighting): the DRC sends a written notice with a deadline to remove the item. You have 15 days to appeal in writing or you waive the appeal.
Source: North River Farms Rules & Regulations (Handbook), Enforcement and Hearing Procedures, Fine Schedule, and Design Review “Failure to comply.” General information, not legal advice.